Advice and litigation on the organization and operation of universities, the recruitment of academic staff, research quality assessment procedures, and the statutory and regulatory autonomy of universities. Assistance in disciplinary proceedings against faculty and researchers, in challenges to acts of university governing bodies, and in litigation over the public funding of universities.
Representation of candidates in challenges to exclusion from competitive procedures, the annulment of tests, or the refusal to recognize a professional qualification. Advice to examination boards and to the administrations that announce competitions on preparing the relevant acts and handling the resulting litigation. Representation before the Regional Administrative Court (TAR) and the Council of State at every stage of the proceedings.
Exclusion from a university competition and failure to obtain the National Scientific Qualification are administrative acts that can be challenged before the TAR within 60 days of notice. The most common grounds concern the unlawful composition of the committee, breach of the pre-established assessment criteria, and inadequate or contradictory reasoning for the negative assessment. The Firm assists candidates from the initial assessment of whether a challenge is well founded through to the hearing before the Council of State.
The interim-relief phase is often decisive in university litigation: the TAR can suspend the recruitment procedure or the appointment, with immediate effects on the university's activities. Handling the interim-relief hearing requires a fast and technically sound response. The Firm assists universities in preparing interim-relief briefs and arguing before the court, with the aim of limiting the effects of any suspension and bringing the case to a hearing on the merits as quickly as possible.
The refusal to recognize a professional qualification obtained in another European Union country can be challenged before the TAR when the decision breaches Directive 2005/36/EC on the recognition of professional qualifications or the principles of EU law on the free movement of professionals. The Firm assists foreign and Italian professionals who wish to challenge decisions of the competent authorities on the recognition of qualifications.
Disciplinary proceedings against a university professor are first conducted before the university's internal bodies, with procedural safeguards that include the right to be heard and to file written defenses. The professor may be assisted by a lawyer from this stage, which often determines the outcome: the arguments submitted internally shape the room for maneuver in any subsequent administrative litigation before the TAR if a disciplinary measure is adopted.