With its experience in administrative and corporate law, the Firm assists businesses, trade associations, and local authorities on the rules governing commercial activities, sector-specific administrative authorizations, and proceedings relating to local economic development.

The Firm also advises Italian and foreign businesses on international trade law, particularly distribution, agency, and commercial joint venture agreements. In this field, the Firm has long-standing working relationships with leading international law firms, which allows it to assist clients on issues involving foreign legal systems.

Commerce, Business Activities, and Local Development

Local administrative regulation and freedom of enterprise: where administrative law meets business activity.

Commerce, Business Activities, and Local Development

Business regulation is one of the areas where local, regional, and national rules overlap most chaotically. A municipal regulation on opening hours, a regional resolution on commercial permits, or a local economic development plan may contain provisions that conflict with competition law or with the Bolkestein Directive on free access to service activities.

The Firm assists municipalities and regions in drafting commercial regulations and plans that comply with current legislation and can withstand the litigation that often follows.

Questions?

Questions and Answers

Can a municipality limit the number of shops in a given area or product category?

Quantitative limits on opening shops are in principle prohibited by the Bolkestein Directive and the national implementing legislation, unless they are justified by overriding reasons of general interest and are proportionate and non-discriminatory. The administrative courts have annulled numerous municipal regulations that imposed limits failing these criteria. The Firm represents retailers and trade associations in challenges to such measures and advises in advance on whether they are lawful.

Can a business whose commercial permit has been revoked keep operating while it challenges the revocation?

Revocation of a commercial permit takes effect immediately, but a party challenging it before the Regional Administrative Court (TAR) can ask for the decision to be stayed. The administrative court grants a stay when there are serious grounds of unlawfulness and when immediate enforcement would cause severe and hard-to-reverse harm. The Firm assesses the merits of an interim-relief request case by case and assists throughout the challenge.

Must a local authority that wants to support local businesses with grants or incentives comply with State aid rules?

Any measure that uses public resources to give a selective advantage to certain businesses or sectors is subject to State aid rules, unless it falls within one of the exemption categories provided for by EU regulations. Local authorities that grant aid without checking compliance with EU law expose themselves to recovery proceedings by the Commission, with the cost borne by the beneficiary. The Firm assists authorities in designing compliant measures and represents businesses in recovery proceedings.

Does a foreign company opening a business in Italy face different permitting procedures from Italian companies?

The principle of non-discrimination enshrined in the Bolkestein Directive and the EU Treaties prohibits Member States from imposing on businesses from other EU countries market-access conditions more burdensome than those applied to domestic businesses. Permitting procedures must be equivalent, and the requirements imposed must be proportionate and justified. The Firm assists foreign economic operators planning to start commercial activities in Italy in checking the applicable requirements and in challenging discriminatory measures.