Public Utilities, Infrastructure, and Energy

The Firm acts for infrastructure operators, public service concessionaires, energy companies, and public administrations in regulatory proceedings, in disputes before sector authorities, and in cases before the Regional Administrative Court (TAR) and the Council of State. Its clients include railway and airport companies and major national network operators.

EXPERIENCE IN Utilities, Infrastructure, and Energy

Where the Firm Works on a Regular Basis

Transport, Airports, and Ports

Advice and litigation in proceedings involving airport operators, railway companies, port authorities, and local public transport operators. Assistance in dealings with the sector’s regulatory authorities, in award procedures for infrastructure concessions, and in litigation arising from the management of critical infrastructure.

Energy

Assistance in administrative proceedings and litigation involving producers, distributors, and suppliers of electricity and gas, renewable energy operators, and operators of strategic energy infrastructure. Advice on dealings with the Regulatory Authority for Energy, Networks and Environment (ARERA) and on permitting procedures for generation plants and distribution networks.

Waste Management

Advice and litigation on the award and management of collection, treatment, and disposal services for municipal and special waste. Assistance in permitting procedures for facilities and in disputes between operators, municipalities, and local area authorities (autorità d’ambito), with attention to environmental liability arising from the management of the service.

Public Utilities, Infrastructure, and Energy

Critical infrastructure and strategic concessions: what sets them apart from any other administrative litigation.

Public Utilities, Infrastructure, and Energy

Cases involving infrastructure such as airports, rail networks, ports, and energy facilities have one feature that sets them apart from most ordinary administrative litigation: the effects of a decision affecting these operators spread immediately to a very wide range of users, connected businesses, and overlapping public interests.

The Firm has direct experience assisting national infrastructure operators that work under concession. In these settings, advice often comes before litigation: supporting the client as the concession relationship is structured, as terms are negotiated with the granting authority, and as acts are checked against sector rules significantly reduces exposure to future disputes.

Questions?

Questions and Answers

Can the operator of a local public service challenge the refusal to extend its concession?

A refusal to extend a public service concession is an administrative decision that can be challenged before the TAR, but the scope for challenge depends on the terms of the concession contract, the applicable sector rules, and the case law of the Council of State on the award of local public services. The Firm assesses the operator's position from both the contractual and the regulatory standpoint and assists in the interim-relief phase when the refusal immediately affects the continuity of the service.

What can a renewable energy operator do if an incentive already granted is revoked or reduced?

The retroactive revocation or reduction of renewable energy incentives has been one of the most active areas of litigation before the TAR and the Council of State in recent years. The case law has set precise criteria on legitimate expectations and on the limits of the administration's power to review its own decisions (autotutela) in this sector. The Firm represents energy operators in challenges to these measures, drawing on experience with the specific case history of the renewables sector in Italy.

Can a port or airport authority unilaterally change the terms of an existing concession?

Unilateral changes to concession terms are subject to precise limits set by legislation and administrative case law. In principle, the granting authority may exercise its power to amend for supervening reasons of public interest, but it must compensate the concessionaire for the economic consequences of the change and respect the concessionaire's right to be heard. The Firm assists port and airport concessionaires in assessing whether such changes are lawful and in any resulting litigation.

Must a municipality hold a public tender to award its waste management service?

How the waste management service may be awarded depends on the legislation on local public services of general economic interest and on ARERA's rules for the sector. A direct award is permitted only where the strict conditions laid down by law are met, such as an in-house award to a company wholly owned by the authority that satisfies the "similar control" test (controllo analogo). The Firm assists municipalities in verifying whether the chosen award method is lawful and represents private operators who wish to challenge direct awards they consider unlawful.